Did I Overreact?

This morning Tori and Alexis were all ready for school, and they were sitting at the counter eating cereal for breakfast. They weren't very happy with the cereal selection so they were pouting a little. I ran upstairs to grab something, and when I came back down they looked happy as ever! "Oh did you decide you liked the cereal?" I asked. To which they replied "no, but we like the popcorn chicken!" Panic began to set in as I realized that they were eating the leftover popcorn chicken from lunch THE DAY BEFORE! It was still sitting out on the counter (which embarrassingly shows how on top of doing the dishes I am). But that aside, I was a little freaked out. I informed them that they were now probably going to get really really sick, and why would they ever think that eating old chicken was a good idea!! I admit I may have overreacted a little bit. I told them I had to go ask dad if he thought we needed to get their stomachs pumped (ok. ok, I know...MAJOR overreaction) I didn't actually think we would have to do that, but I wanted to scare them a little. (I am so mean!!!) Anyways, after talking to Brandon we decided that they better stay home just in case it did make them sick. I told them they better go back to bed and wait for the stomach aches to set in. Well to make a long story short, they were fine all day. Am I wrong in thinking that day old chicken sitting out on the counter is kind of bad to eat?? My mom and sister seemed to sympathize, but tonight I had a dad of a little girl in Tori's Daisy troop come by to pick up girl scout cookies. He said that his wife said to ask if Tori was ok, since she wasn't in school. So I told him the whole story thinking that he would sympathize as well, to which I just received a blank stare that seemed to say, 'You are weird'. I am very relieved that they are fine, but I am starting to feel silly for making such a big deal out of it....